Does Brain Training Work? The Question of Transfer
If you practice a memory game repeatedly, you may become better at that game. The more important question is what changes outside it. Do you remember appointments more reliably, understand difficult material more easily, or perform better at work? These are different outcomes, and evidence for one does not automatically establish the others.
Brain training is a broad label for activities marketed or studied as ways to improve cognitive performance. The activities vary, as do the populations, training schedules, and outcomes. Asking whether all brain training “works” without specifying the intended benefit creates a question too vague for a useful answer.
The central scientific issue is transfer: whether improvement extends beyond the practiced activity. A careful answer distinguishes improvement on trained tasks, improvement on similar untrained tasks, and broader benefits in everyday functioning.
Three levels of improvement
Getting better at the trained task
With practice, participants can learn the rules, recognize recurring patterns, adopt strategies, and respond more efficiently. An improved score is real performance improvement, but its scope may be narrow.
For example, a person might learn how a particular sequence game presents information and become skilled at grouping its items. That does not necessarily mean their memory has improved equally for names, conversations, or complex instructions.
A higher score is therefore a starting point for evaluation, not the final demonstration of a general cognitive benefit.
Near transfer
Near transfer refers to improvement on untrained tasks that share relevant features with the training. A second task may use similar materials, response demands, or strategies.
This can be useful evidence, especially if the outcome is genuinely untrained. However, a task described as “new” may still closely resemble the practiced activity. The degree of overlap matters when interpreting what has generalized.
Near transfer should be described at the level supported by the tasks. It does not automatically imply broad improvement in intelligence or daily functioning.
Far transfer
Far transfer concerns benefits on more distantly related outcomes. Depending on the claim, this might involve academic performance, general reasoning, workplace functioning, or everyday memory.
Such benefits are especially important to consumers, but they are also harder to establish convincingly. Many factors influence these outcomes, and a study must separate the specific contribution of training from expectations, repeated testing, and other differences between groups.
The farther the promise extends from the practiced activity, the more important it is to inspect the actual evidence supporting that extension.
What a major evidence review found
A comprehensive 2016 review by Daniel Simons and colleagues examined claims about brain-training programs and the evidence behind them. The review distinguished substantial evidence for improvement on trained tasks from less convincing evidence for broader transfer, particularly to everyday cognitive performance.
This does not justify saying that every possible training program is ineffective for every person and outcome. It does justify skepticism toward broad claims that practice on a set of games reliably produces generalized cognitive improvement.
The review also emphasized methodological issues. A convincing study needs appropriate controls, suitable outcome measures, and analyses that do not turn a few favorable results into a sweeping conclusion.
Because products and research continue to change, a specific program should be judged on evidence for its current version and intended use. The general lesson remains: the outcome advertised must match the outcome actually tested.
Why neuroplasticity is not enough to prove effectiveness
Learning involves changes in the nervous system. That broad fact is often used in marketing as if it validates a particular program's benefits.
But “the brain changes” and “this activity improves the function you care about” are different claims. A change can reflect learning the game, adapting to its demands, or becoming familiar with the testing situation. It need not produce a useful improvement elsewhere.
Our guide to neuroplasticity explains why plasticity is a property of the nervous system rather than a guarantee that every intervention works. The direction, specificity, and practical significance of a change still need evidence.
Likewise, a colorful brain image cannot substitute for a behavioral outcome. If a program promises better everyday memory, researchers should measure everyday memory in a credible way, not rely solely on a neural signal that changed after training.
What makes a comparison group useful?
A group that does nothing can help establish whether an intervention differs from no intervention. However, it may not control for the experience of receiving an engaging activity, attention from researchers, or an expectation of improvement.
An active comparison group performs another activity. Ideally, that activity is credible and sufficiently similar in relevant nonspecific features, while differing in the mechanism being tested.
For example, if participants in one group receive an exciting program advertised as cognitive enhancement and the other group receives an obviously uninteresting task, expectations may differ. Any observed advantage becomes harder to attribute exclusively to the proposed training mechanism.
No control condition is perfect. The point is to ask which alternative explanations the design addresses and which remain plausible. Random assignment helps with comparability, but it does not automatically solve every measurement or expectation problem.
Repeated testing can look like improvement
Taking a test once can make a later attempt easier. Participants may understand the instructions better, become familiar with the format, or remember aspects of the task.
If everyone improves after a training period, that pattern alone does not show that training caused the change. A suitable comparison helps estimate how much improvement would occur through repeated assessment or other shared experiences.
The timing of measurement matters too. A benefit observed immediately after practice may not persist. Follow-up assessments are needed to support claims about lasting improvement.
Researchers should also distinguish a statistically detectable difference from an improvement large enough to matter. A small advantage on a laboratory score may have limited relevance to the daily outcome a consumer wants.
How multiple outcomes can mislead
A study may assess many cognitive tasks. Some results may favor training while others show little difference. Highlighting only the favorable outcomes creates a distorted impression of consistency.
A stronger report makes the planned primary outcomes clear, explains how multiple comparisons were handled, and presents unfavorable or uncertain findings as well as positive ones. Preregistration can make it easier to distinguish planned tests from exploratory analysis.
Exploratory findings are not worthless. They can suggest promising questions for future research. The problem arises when an exploratory pattern is marketed as an established benefit without adequate confirmation.
For readers, a useful question is whether the claimed improvement appears across relevant measures and independent studies, or rests on one selected score from a large set of tests.
Population matters
Evidence from one group should not automatically be extended to another. Results involving healthy young adults, older adults, children, or people receiving rehabilitation answer different questions.
A targeted rehabilitation intervention may have a specific functional goal and be delivered in a clinical context. It should not be treated as equivalent to a general consumer game simply because both involve practice.
Similarly, a program studied in a narrowly selected sample may not have established the same benefit for everyone who encounters its advertisement. The relevant comparison is between the study population and the people for whom the claim is being made.
If the concern is a new or worsening cognitive difficulty, buying a game is not a substitute for appropriate assessment. Training evidence should not be stretched into claims about preventing or treating disease without relevant clinical support.
A practical way to evaluate a program
Start by naming the outcome you want. “A sharper brain” is difficult to evaluate. Remembering scheduled tasks, learning a language, or performing a specific professional skill gives you a more concrete target.
Next, ask whether the program has been tested on that outcome. A memory-game score is not evidence for all forms of memory. A short reasoning test is not automatically evidence for improved job performance.
Inspect the comparison, sample, and follow-up. Look for independent research and clear reporting of limitations. Testimonials can describe satisfaction, but they cannot establish that the program caused a general benefit.
Finally, consider opportunity cost. Time spent on an enjoyable game may be worthwhile as recreation. If your goal is mastering a particular skill, practicing that skill and measuring relevant progress may provide a more direct route. This is a decision about your goal, not a claim that all indirect training is impossible.
What to do instead of chasing a general score
For learning a subject, use methods that target retention and understanding of that subject. Test yourself on the material, return to it over time, and practice applying it to the kinds of problems you want to solve.
For remembering everyday intentions, improve the cues and systems that support the intended action. A calendar reminder at the relevant moment addresses a different problem from increasing performance on a visual sequence game.
For a work skill, identify the errors that matter and practice with feedback under appropriately realistic conditions. Improvement should be measured in the activity you want to perform better.
These examples do not promise universal enhancement. They align the practice and the outcome, making success easier to evaluate and reducing reliance on a vague claim of general brain optimization.
Frequently asked questions
Are brain-training games useless?
No blanket conclusion is necessary. They can be enjoyable and can improve performance on practiced activities. Broader claims require evidence for the specific transfer outcome.
Does a harder game produce more transfer?
Difficulty alone does not establish transfer. A demanding task can remain highly specific. The relevant question is whether independent measures show the desired benefit.
Does improved working memory mean higher intelligence?
Not automatically. Working memory is not interchangeable with every cognitive ability, and an improved score may reflect task-specific learning. A claim about general reasoning needs its own appropriate evidence.
How long should training benefits last?
There is no universal duration across programs and outcomes. A lasting-benefit claim should be supported by follow-up measurements rather than inferred from an immediate post-training test.
Sources
- Simons, D. J., Boot, W. R., Charness, N., Gathercole, S. E., Chabris, C. F., Hambrick, D. Z., & Stine-Morrow, E. A. L. (2016). Do “Brain-Training” Programs Work? Psychological Science in the Public Interest. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27697851/